eCourts
Civil Cases
Judgements
Insolvencies
Judicial Sales
Hall Usage
Services
Get Mobile Notifications
Pay Court Fines
Pay Court Registry Fees
Help
Chat
Malti
English
Log In
Home
Search Judgements
Details
Reference: 538/1996/1
Download
Judgement Details
Date
09/02/2000
Court
CIVIL FIRST HALL (CONSTITUTIONAL JURISDICTION)
Judiciary
DE GAETANO VINCENT
Parties
BONAVIA VICTOR vs L-AWTORITA TAL-IPPJANAR
ECLI
N/A
Judgement Type
NOT AVAILABLE
Linked Case
BONAVIA VICTOR vs L-AWTORITA TAL-IPPJANAR - 538/1996/1 - CIVIL FIRST HALL (CONSTITUTIONAL JURISDICTION), MALTA
Keywords / Summary
Keywords
DISKRIMINAZZJONI - SMIGH XIERAQ
Summary
F'dan il-kaz,ir-rikorrent jghid li la kellu smigh xieraq quddiem l-Awtorita` ta' l-Ippjanar u anqasquddiem il-Bord ta' l-Appell dwar l-Ippjanar.
Kien jinkombi fuq ir-rikorrent li jipprova lima kellux smigh xieraq, u tali prova ma ingabitx. Jekk, mill-banda l-ohra, r-rikorrent qed jghidli ma kellux smigh xieraq ghax il-ligi ma tipprovdilux access ghal Qorti li setghet tinvestiga il-proporzjonalita` bejn l-iskop pubbliku fid-dikjarazzjoni tas-sensitivita` ambjentali tas-sit u d-drittijiet tieghu, allura l-lanjanza tar-rikorrent kellha tkun indirizzata lejn il-Gvern, rappresentat mill-Prim Ministru jew mill-Avukat Generali (skond meta jkun gie intavolat ir-rikors) u mhux lejnl-Awtorita` ta' l-Ippjanar, wisq anqas lejn il-Bord. Ghalhekk din il-Qorti ma tarax li tista' takkolji l-ilment tar-rikorrent ibbazat fuq l-Artikolu 6 tal-Konvenzjoni.
Rigward l-Artikolu 1 ta'l-Ewwel Protokoll tal-Konvenzjoni, dan jipprovdi tlett regoli distinti pero` interkonnessi: (1) Kullpersuna naturali jew persuna morali ghandha dritt ghat-tgawdija pacifika tal-possedimenti taghha. (2) Hadd ma ghandu jigi pprivat mill-possedimenti tieghu hlief fl-interess pubbliku u bla hsara tal-kundizzjonijiet provduti bil-ligi u bil-principji generali tal-ligi internazzjonali. (3) Izda d-disposizzjonijiet ta' qabel ma ghandhom b'ebda mod inaqqsu d-dritt ta' Stat li jwettaq dawk il-ligijiet li jidhrulu xierqa biex jikkontrolla l-uzu ta' proprjeta` skond l-interess generali jew biex jizgural-hlas ta' taxxi jew kontribuzzjonijiet ohra jew pieni.
L-essenza tad-diskriminazzjoni tikkonsisti filli jinghata trattament differenti ghal kazijiet ugwali. Fil-gurisprudenza ta' Strasbourg tintuza spiss flok il-kelma equal il-kelma similar. Hekk, per ezempju, fil-kaz ta' Spadea and Scalabrino (deciz fit-28 ta' Settembru, 1995) jinghad hekk:
Article 14 will be breached where, without objective and reasonable justification, persons in relevantly' similar situations are treated differently. For a claim of violation of this Article to succeed, it has therefore to be established,inter alia, that the situation of the alleged victim can be considered similar to that of persons who have been better treated (A. 315-B, p.28).
Fi kliem l-awturi van Dijk u van Hoof, fit-tielet edizzjoni tal-ktieb taghhom Theory and Practice of the European Convention on Human Rights (Kluwer, The Hague, 1998),
A violation of the principle of equality and non-discrimination arises ifthere is (a) differential treatment (b) of equal cases (c) without there being an objective and reasonable justification, or if (d) proportionality between the aim sought and the means employed is lacking (p. 719).
F'dan il-kaz, ir-rikorrent qed jallega li saret diskriminazzjoni fil-konfront tieghu mill-Awtorita` intimata u mill-Bord peress li l-area tal-Maghtab hija committed ghal farms u farmhouses, u filwaqt li inghataw permessi f'dik l-area ghall-bini ta' farms lil haddiehor,lilu l-permess ma inhariglux.
Din il-Qorti ma taqbilx mar-rikorrenti u ghaldaqstant tichadit-talbiet tieghu.
Click here to search again.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies.
More Info
Got It