Reference: 73/2011/1

Judgement Details


Date
06/02/2015
Court
CONSTITUTIONAL
Judiciary
CAMILLERI SILVIO, CARUANA DEMAJO GIANNINO, CUSCHIERI NOEL
Parties
BRADSHAW SEAN ET vs L-AVUKAT GENERALI ET
Judgement Type
FINAL JUDGEMENT

Appealed Details


Appealed
Yes

Keywords / Summary


Summary
Dan il-kaz kien jirrigwarda l-allegata l-inkostituzzjonalita ta' ligi. Il-Qorti ma qablitx mal-ewwelQorti li l-kazin involut kellu jbati parti mill-kumpens fissat mill-ewwel Qorti ghal-lezjoni sofferta mill-atturi minhabba li l-ligi, applikata mill-kazin, kienet leziva tad-drittijiet fundamentali taghhom. Ladarba l-kazin agixxa fil-parametri tal-ligi huwa ma kellux jigi kkundannat ihallas partimill-kumpens fissat mill-Qorti. Ghax il-ligi jaghmilha l-Istat, mhux ic-cittadin li, minn naha tieghu, ghandu dritt juzufruwixxi minnha fil-parametri taghha. Ghalhekk fil-kaz ta' ligi leziva tad-drittijiet konvenzjonali jew kostituzzjonali, huwa l-Istat u mhux ic-cittadin li ghandu jirrispondi. Ghax huwa principalment l-obbligu tal-Istat, u mhux tal-inkwilin, li jassigura li d-drittijet fundamentali tas-sid ma jinkissrux




Operational Programme 1
CONvErGE connected eGovernment


We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies. More Info