Reference: 12/2014/1

Judgement Details


Date
16/03/2015
Court
CONSTITUTIONAL
Judiciary
CARUANA DEMAJO GIANNINO, MALLIA TONIO, CUSCHIERI NOEL
Parties
HOLMES DANIEL ALEXANDER vs AVUKAT GENERALI ET
ECLI
ECLI:MT:KOS:2015:93430
Judgement Type
FINAL JUDGEMENT

Keywords / Summary


Summary
Dan kien kaz dwar d-diskrezzjoni tal-Avukat Generali f'kazi ta'droga. Il-ligi trid tithaddem fil-kazkonkret u mhux fl-astratt - seta' jew ma setax jobsor l-attur illi l-gravità tar-reat minnu mwettaqla kienet zghira u lanqas borderline, b'mod illi jekk jinqabad x'aktarx illi jitressaq quddiem il-Qorti Kriminali?
Il-Qorti ikkunsidrat li essenzjalment l-attur kellu production line sostanzjali b'vertical integration tal-process kollu tal-produzzjoni tad-droga. Ma setax realistikament jistennailli r-reat tieghu ma jitqiesx gravi bizzejjed biex jitressaq quddiem il-Qorti Kriminali, kif fil-fatt gara. L-element ta' prevedibilità wkoll tal-punishment bracket, biex jithares dak illi gie interpretat li jrid l-art. 7 ta' Konvenzjoni, ghalhekk ma kienx nieqes.




Operational Programme 1
CONvErGE connected eGovernment


We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies. More Info